A Voice

I've been thinking a lot about my voice. 

 

For a long time on this blog, I felt a silence come over me. I was so terrified to admit (to others and to myself) how very ill I truly was. If I admitted it to my employers, I might lose work, and thus the insurance that would help me return to our regularly scheduled program of overworking my way to out-running self-loathing! 

 

And if I admitted to to myself, my psyche would collapse utterly under the weight of It All, and I might never recover physically or emotionally.  

 

But yes. If you've stuck around here long enough, you probably noticed I was doing quite the fancy thing there for a while, and now, (as a close friend so recently, dismissively? callously? maybe totally innocently? labeled me—) I am "a regional theatre actress." 

 

For the record, nothing about that label is shameful, and of course, nothing about the quality of my work has altered. Careers are not at all the meritocracies we were promised in school. They are often merely the luck of who you know, where you were, if you had support, how audacious you were, the draw of fate, and the geography of the work itself. I had a lot of those. I didn't have others. I'd also add that in emerging years... I am much more than "just" an actress, as my literal tax return would point out. 

But I digress. 

 

For this friend is not wrong: I acknowledge that once upon a time, I was a big West End leading lady in the making, and then had a lot of fancy classical music gigs and 2 Broadway shows under my belt. And since 2017 I haven't acted in those spaces in a while. And my health is largely responsible for that.  

 

It's taken me years to recognize what actually occurred in my body and in my career, and it is one of the great griefs of my life that the singing experience—once such a source of pure joy and release—has become so fraught, even though it is now, largely in my psychology. 

 

____ 

 

Around 2014 I started to notice a change in my body, which included a change in my singing voice. I couldn't place it. I couldn't fix it. I couldn't even totally name what was happening, but it felt like this: 

after a lifetime of holding a pencil and knowing how to write with it, suddenly one day I picked up the pencil and it started to fall gracelessly out of my grip without ceremony. Nothing I did could regain the control i worked so hard to enjoy. And this was right at the moment I was the most visible on earth as "a singer." Oy.

I now realize it was the beginnings of a terrible illness that would take much more from me than merely a effortlessly floaty passagio. It would take momentum. Relationships. Years of my and off my, life. It would take literal organs. It would take my fertility. And of course, it ravaged the most sensitive part of my body to all of this: my voice. 39 failed medications. Years of physical pain in the form of body tension that still lives in my fascia to this day. And as they say of racehorses: "an injured champion never races the same..." 

 

I'm learning, as I heal all this that though not at all unusual, over the years mind did something horrible. It did not simply do say: 

"I grieve what my instrument used to do."

or

"I grieve the life I could have had, had my instrument remained on what I felt was a promised trajectory" 

 

But almost immediately:

"What does this mean about me as a human being?"

 

Those are two utterly different griefs.
One is grief over a legitimate loss.
The other is utter shame.

The first says:

"Something precious changed."

 

The second says:

"I became less worthy."

 

Those are not the same emotion. But trauma often fuses them together until they feel indissoluble. 

This was not a change I could understand. For someone whose nervous system learned that understanding equals safety, that is an almost unbearable request. 

  

I no longer feel that my voice is broken or damaged. But it is not remotely what it was in 2013. Partly because I haven't been able to "get the reps in." But the soaring has returned, when i am asked to soar. And it means even more to soar when one has learned what it means to fall out of the sky. 

 

And lately, life has been teaching me to challenge a lifelong strategy. 

 

My instinct has always been to "make meaning" of events. I am compelled to make meaning, to analyze, to build a coherent narrative before I even fully feel the emotion. A self protection, of course. And not a sustainable one. 

This year has not allowed that.
 

This year of expansion is asking me to relinquish mastery. Certainty. Perfection. And replace it with curiosity. Space. Wonder. Awe. To relish all I do now know, throw my head back and laugh at all I have yet to learn and do and become.

  
To cease not only striving for perfection, 

        but performing the illusion of perfection. 

© hula seventy

Farewell, Désirée

There are some roles you play, and there are some roles that play you back.

 

Désirée Armfeldt, I have discovered, belongs firmly in the second category. The woman who met me exactly as I was becoming ready to inhabit my own life more fully...

 

And now, apparently, I am supposed to say goodbye to her.

For now. (For now, universe. I am making eye contact with you...)

But the glorious lesson of The Theatre is the lesson of ephemeral beauty, the ever-fleeting impermanence of It All, and in that truth lies a divine gift: that to love anything means we will lose it. And that the axiom "this too shall pass" is just as true of joyful moments as it is of adverse ones. May we relish the good times while they are here, for soon they will ebb once more. 

 

Such is life. 

 

So for now, the kimono goes back. The wig goes back. The glorious Lady-Gaga's-PLEAT-GUY-pleated-this-handmade-Fortuni-gown gowns go back. The makeup comes off. The dressing room empties. And once again I am confronted by the specific, beautiful, brutality of theatre: that we build an entire world together, furnish it with our bodies, our hearts, our neuroses, our snacks, and an alarming quantity of pins, and then one night we simply stop.

Poof.

Gone.

 

Cheers.

 

Which feels particularly strange because the last five months have been among the most expansive of my life.

There was Brigadoon—a piece I had spent years loving, interrogating, rewriting, fighting for, and finally watching become real in front of actual human beings. 

There was Chicago. 

There was Désirée. 

There was turning forty-three.

There were new friendships.

And old friendships returning in surprising new shapes.

There was writing.

There was acting.

There was (fraught but ultimately satisfying) singing.

There were meetings with exciting people. 

There were rooms full of artists imagining impossible things! And then, through some combination of craft, caffeine, delusion, and a text thread or three, making them possible.

 

And somewhere inside all of that, something in me began to soften. From my mindset to my nervous system to perhaps even to my literal fascia? I'm softer. Or life doesn't feel so hard. Or some semblance of both.  

______

Ah, softening. 

For most of the first half of my life, I believed strength meant bracing:

Prepare for the blow.

Anticipate the loss.

Read the room.

Make yourself useful.

Make yourself excellent.

Make yourself indispensable.

Make yourself whatever shape might prevent catastrophe.

And then life, with its usual lack of subtlety, eventually taught me that no amount of bracing can stop life from being life.

People leave.

Bodies change.

Careers zigzag.

Health fails.

Plans explode.

Love arrives anyway.

New identities present themselves with or without your consent.  

 

So perhaps this "middle-aged growing up journey" I'm on, is not at all about learning how to brace more effectively.

It is, I suspect, discovering that I no longer have to. (Isn't THAT rich?)

 

That is one of the gifts Désirée gave me. 

She is, after all, a woman who has spent much of her life moving.

City to city.

Stage to stage.

Affair to affair.

Performance to performance.

Always admired.

Always desired.

Always slightly elsewhere.

 

And then, suddenly, she wants something different.

Not applause.

Not admiration.

Not another dazzling entrance.

Home.

And I know that I understand that differently now than I would have ten years ago.

Home, I now realize, is not really a place at all. 

Home may be allowing yourself to be loved without immediately wondering how you can repay it.

Home may be trusting that the people who love you are not secretly conducting quarterly performance reviews.

Home may be waking up inside a body that has survived extraordinary things and finally regarding it not as a problem to solve, but as the astonishing vehicle that carried you here.

 

I have spent a great deal of my life trying to "earn" safety. I am beginning, tentatively, to believe I might simply... have some?

 

And of course, this has changed the way I think about my work, too.

For years I felt an invisible pressure to choose. To "brand." To "pick a market." Woe betide the mid 2000s and all their "so many years of muddle." 

Are you an actor? A singer?

Or are you an educator?  

Or wait: are you a writer?

Are you truly serious about performing?

Or serious about making your own work?

 

Pick a lane, Silber, the world is waiting. (Preferably before everyone notices you are driving several vehicles at once...)

 

But lately I have started wondering:

Why? WTF? Who made that rule?

 

I have always been suspicious of false binaries, and yet somehow I had constructed an enormous one inside my own career.

Actor OR writer.

Interpreter OR maker.

But what if the answer is simply:

Yes.

I am a woman standing backstage in a corset five minutes before places thinking about sentence structure. 

I am ALL.

"Applause for the clowns. They're finally here..." 

And perhaps my life is spacious enough to hold all of it.

 

Perhaps that is true for you, too. I don't know you, dear reader, but I suspect that we all contain multitudes.  

 

So aside from being overwhelming in its feeling of "midlife tardiness," this realization feels enormous not because it means I must now do everything at once (which is exactly the sort of conclusion my nervous system used to draw automatically, but, frankly we are no longer letting her run the meeting...) it means I don't have to amputate pieces of myself in order to appear coherent. My coherence may be entirely about embracing the combination. The All. The All of AL! 

 

And while I may moan and weep about how long it took me to heal and get a grip and make these discoveries, one of the strange gifts of midlife is realizing how much time has passed us by while simultaneously discovering how much life might still be waiting. Ahead. Still. 

There is grief in that. Of course. 

But there is also tremendous freedom.

I am no longer "waiting to become the person who gets to relax and just live my life."

 

She is already here. 

 ______

So farewell for now, Désirée.

 

Thank you for finding me at exactly this moment.

Thank you for asking harder questions than I expected.

Thank you for reminding me that growing older is not the diminishment I once feared, but perhaps an invitation to become more.

 

More honest.

More ridiculous.

More true.  

More absolutely alive.

 

There is still so much I want.

 

And for the first time in a long time, wanting does not feel like evidence of lack.

It feels like evidence that I am here.

 

Still becoming.

 

Still beginning.

Still.

©Joe Mazza / Brave Lux (of course)